Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Danny While this thread is still alive... am I misinterpreting, or were the lyrics on ...Is a Real Boy occasionally pretty misogynistic? I'm thinking of "The Writhing South" and "Slowly, Through a Vector" mainly...the latter of which I can't even stomach listening to because of the lyrics in the bridge. But beyond that, all of them that relate to women seem to portray them literally as nothing but sex objects. (Ironic, considering the lyrics I have in my signature right now...perhaps Molly Connolly really did leave a strong, sour taste in his mouth?) The new song on their site seems to display this attitude, as well...what's the deal? |
I think you're reading too deeply. Does talking about girls having sex make one misogynistic? I'm not seeing the misogynistic slant in "The Writhing South." But I'll get to that.
I would say "risqué" instead of misogynistic. "Slowly, Through a Vector" is now one of my top ten favorite songs of all time, and I think there's more to the lyrics there than misogynism.
The lyrics to "Slowly, Through a Vector" are deliciously elusive. While most post-punk lyricists are writing like Palahniuk, Bemis is clearly Thomas Pynchon. Most post-punk lyricists are self-satisfied with appearing counter-cultural and deep. Bemis is more interesting in painting ****ed-up scenarios where he is a lone man of sanity jealous of the insanity around him.
First off, there's nothing in the lyrics of "Slowly, Through a Vector" that implies the protagonist's abused darling is a female. That must be your naturally- or culturally-ingrained heterosexual wiring (wink), or perhaps you're just looking at the context of the rest of the album. I like Bemis to be ruggedly heterosexual (as am I), but I'd be interested to see him do what Stephen Merritt does and switch genders in his narration. But anyway...
The opening of the song (that I misheard as "to form her business sector," instead of "former business sector") seems to portray a protagonist seemingly on a field of battle or just before a battle - with terms like "vector" or "lives that blink" it seems either like military imagery or Halo (I don't play video games, pardon me if I don't understand Halo). The setting seems to be a ruined city.
So the first verse is the protagonist thinking about his immediate setting. The second verse deals with his emotions, using his warrior-like prowling of the city to voice his complaints over a relationship. He bellows a challenge or a cry of vindication out to him/her across the ruined landscape. But s/he is beyond his control and amidst problems of his/her own.
At last he arrives at his beloved's apartment, to find him/her victimized. He is unable to save him/her, and can only satisfy himself in cleaning up the mess. But since the second verse seems to testify that they had a strong disagreement and clash, perhaps the bridge is a metaphor for the protagonist leaving his beloved to his/her devices until his/her bad choices tear him/her apart?
He does watch - which in the context of the album seems to me to be more self-satisfaction (whoop! bad word choice) that someone who didn't follow his ways fell apart.
That being said, "Slowly, Through a Vector" seems to have no definite meaning. That makes it a breath of fresh air next to more blunt tracks (yet also good) such as "Woe" or "Admit It!!!" that heap on Bemis' thoughts directly. Who knows what in Asgard is conclusively going on in "Slowly, Through a Vector?"
Now, "The Writhing South" seems to chronicle the protagonist's urges as he makes his way across a Southern town, paranoid and low on energy. He sees a girl writhing, and it's like she begging him to have his way with her ("Come pollinate me," which paints a sort of passive bee/flower image - she's putting on her best to attract him, but he'll be the aggressor). He'll spend his last bit of dough to get her in his grasp so they can indulge themselves. Like this situation, the music is frantic and dark.
The orgasmic cries Bemis emits during the breakdown seems to point to this.
In "Yellow Cat/Red Cat," we hear that the sad old writer in the cafe may seem like a lech, but he's ultimately looking for a companion to satisfy both his sexual urges and his need for protection.
"Every Man Has a Molly" is to me the least interesting (musically and lyrically) song on the album. But to call it misogynistic would mean calling every Weezer album the same - it's just a heartbreak/break-up song, albeit with R-rated language.
Unbridled sexuality seems to channel itself both into Bemis' lyrics and music. Keep in mind these songs were based on a rock opera in which the star (Bemis himself, I believe) was unable to control a epic score of post-punk that would erupt from his mouth to describe his situations and feelings. This odd miracles sends him to stardom, but he eventually burns out.
The miracle of his sudden ability to weave operas out of thin air is very much like an orgasm - a pent-up desire that erupts with a loss of control to the one experiencing it. An orgasm is an involuntary response, and Bemis seems to equate this with art and emotion - both come out whether they're accepted by their audience or not.
Additionally, Bemis paints a picture of a protagonist who is at fault for much of his suffering but blames external sources - ultimately he'll admit (in the song "The Futile") that nothing has meaning. So he forces the evil he wants to perceive onto others, and the women who jilt his love and sex and the audiences who don't understand his involuntary need to create art become villains at times, and loved ones at other times (he wants to save them, as in "Belt" when he gathers a crowd or "Slowly, Through a Vector" when he paints himself as a mercenary who arrives just too late to save someone).
Bemix is very vulgar at times, I'll concede that. But I think misogynistic is an incorrect term. He seems to have less of a problem with women themselves as he does the realization of his desires.
By the way, almost every song on the album seems to rise to a frantic or dramatic close, with often a soft or disconnected opening. Whether this was intentionally meant to mirror sex, I can only conjecture. I think Bemis subconsciously channels a lot of his rage and libido into his structure without knowing it until afterwards.