Quote:
Originally Posted by Skeeter Have you read Neil Gaiman's "American Gods" at all? If so, what did you think about it? |
I enjoyed it, but it didn't stick with me. The things I liked in particular was his depiction of the tribe crossing the Bering Strait and the "new" gods (in name only, since they were personifications). I couldn't tell if his use of the various gods was supposed to be sly, as they seemed pretty obvious from first introduction. I am, perhaps (this is meant with humility) a reader with the same level of mythological knowledge as Gaiman, so he'd probably counter that what were "clues" for the average readers were obvious to me and if it had been about, say, famous footballers I wouldn't have had a clue.
I didn't mind the absence of Greek gods, but it was odd to have Norse and Egyptian gods, given that
no immigrants brought the latter over, and the only bringing the Norse were that one group of the Norse in the time before Columbus. It seemed like Gaiman just wanted to play with those gods and wanted to weave a tale of America. In all honesty, more hoodoo/African gods would have made sense, and the general lack of Native American and Judeo-Christian spirits was...weird.
So, in essence, I enjoyed the novel but felt his ideas were undeveloped and the end was a bit unsatisfying. Gaiman, as a British citizen, doesn't understand the American soul as well as he seems to think. Alan Moore nailed us in
Watchmen, except for that whole "chewing sugars" thing.
The idea that belief empowers deities first appears in
Sandman, but Gaiman seemed to be influenced by Alan Moore's ideas of divinity.
Fortunately, my story isn't going to tread on the same locations and is more
Paradise Lost or
Orlando Furioso than
Sandman.
The gods in my tale appear in a way that would please modern psychology.