Go Back   Christian Guitar Forum > Music & Musicians > Logistics > Songwriting
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Arcade Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 12-08-2006, 08:28 PM   #1
is skeptical
 
J_freek's Avatar
 

Joined: Jul 2006
Location: my own little world
Posts: 5,973
Send a message via ICQ to J_freek Send a message via AIM to J_freek Send a message via MSN to J_freek Send a message via Yahoo to J_freek
Untitled. RC

~Chorus~
Please don't tell me I don't know
What it's like not to hurt
I've hurt more than you ever will
I know that you can't just brush it aside and keep on going
I know, that it takes courage, it takes time, it takes faith,
it takes patience, it takes healing
to get back on your feet.

~Verse 1~
And I know that some people say
"It's in the past, so forget about it."
I also know that their still hurting deep down inside
Some people like reliving the hurt.
But I'm not like that,
I need to face my problem.

~Verse 2~
You face your problem
I know it takes courage, it takes time, it takes faith, it takes patience, it take healing
so face your hurt, grip your pain
Before it grips tighter and tighter, choking you to death
I know what it's like when someone let's you down.

~Ending thing~
I can help, I know of One that takes away hurt,
You can be healed.



It's not very good, and needs alot of improvement, but I just sat down and wrote it without paying much attention.

__________________
A Work In Progress

My writings
J_freek is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old 12-14-2006, 06:13 AM   #2
Scarlet. Gray.
 
Small's Avatar
 

Joined: Nov 2004
Location: OH-IO
Posts: 6,021
It's tough to appropriately RC a song like this one--the rhythm isn't continuous from stanza to stanza, and there aren't many rhymes, if any at all.

Still, I suppose a few style points can be eked out.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J_freek View Post
Please don't tell me I don't know
What it's like not to hurt
I've hurt more than you ever will
I know that you can't just brush it aside and keep on going
I know, that it takes courage, it takes time, it takes faith,
it takes patience, it takes healing
to get back on your feet.
The first three lines make no sense. If you've hurt more deeply than 'you' ever will, it is a completely accurate statement to say that you don't know what it is not to hurt. I get the feeling that "not" slipped in by accident.

Quote:
And I know that some people say
"It's in the past, so forget about it."
I also know that their still hurting deep down inside
Some people like reliving the hurt.
But I'm not like that,
I need to face my problem.
I'm having a hard time reading this as a song. It feels precisely like prose broken into lines. The repetition of "some people" could use some alteration. For one thing, it's ambiguous on whether or not it's the same people who are reliving the hurt who are saying that it's all in the past and you should forget about it. Some clarification there would be helpful.


Quote:
You face your problem
I know it takes courage, it takes time, it takes faith, it takes patience, it take healing
so face your hurt, grip your pain
Before it grips tighter and tighter, choking you to death
I know what it's like when someone let's you down.
Some sort of transitional word or phrase would be good here, such as "So you face your problem' or simply "Face your problem." The current opening does nothing for me. It's simply a statement of a fact, a fact that doesn't line up entirely with the rest of the song.

"Grip your pain" and 'before it grips tighter and tighter..." could be a neat turn of phrase if you cleaned it up a little bit, with something as simple as stating what it is the pain is gripping.

The final line is completely incongruous here. There are places in this song it would fit much better than it does here. As it stands, it's simply a sudden change of subject.

Quote:
I can help, I know of One that takes away hurt,
You can be healed.
Very cliched. The first line is also extremely awkward.

Quote:
It's not very good, and needs alot of improvement, but I just sat down and wrote it without paying much attention.
I don't mean to be unduly harsh, but your interests as a songwriter are probably best served by cleaning this one up slightly, for the sake of practice, and then discarding it and starting over. You have one or two interesting ideas that you could transfer to a completely different setting fairly easily.

In fact, it might be worthwhile to pick out your favorite four lines, or even two lines from this song, and to re-write the song based around those four lines.

Two problems I have with this song are that it's cliche, which doesn't make it bad--some cliched songs are excellent--but makes it slightly less interesting, and it's too articulately expository. You spend most of the time simply dropping every nuance of your meaning into the listener's lap, which isn't always bad, but you don't cloak it in rhyme, so you're stuck singing straightforward prose.

Do keep writing, and do keep posting. Good songwriting involves lots of practice, and some tips and critiques along the way.
__________________
No name, no links, no rhymes,
Just two centered lines and a smiley:

Small is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:37 AM.